High street starting to feel the pinch


November 2007

Evidence of a continuing high street slowdown has been published in the CBI's latest monthly retail survey showing that growth in sales is at its slowest for almost a year.

The survey showed 33% of retailers reported a drop in year-on-year sales in the first half of October, against 42% who said sales were up.

The rounded balance of +10% is the weakest since November 2006 and, for the third month in a row below the long-term average of +18%, indicating that the impact of five interest rate rises in a year is now being felt by consumers.

Sales were also weaker than predicted for the second month in a row. Expectation remains hopeful again for November (+15%), though sales are set to remain broadly average for the time of year.

The three month average in sales volumes, which tracks the underlying trend, continued its month-by-month slowdown from May's peak of +36% to +12%, the lowest balance since last December.

The CBI's October's Distributive Trades Survey was conducted between 27th September and 17th October, covering more than 20,000 outlets and 40% of retail jobs. There were 146 respondents.

By sector, sales growth was mixed. Clothing retailers again reported a drop on 12 months earlier (a balance of -39%), with sales falling for five consecutive months. This latest sharp fall in sales on a year ago could reflect a reluctance to buy autumn ranges after a dreary summer and now with relative warmth for the time of year. Meanwhile, after five months of negative figures, durable household goods saw a leap in sales.

Retailers' expectations for orders placed with their suppliers were met exactly. After last month's slight slowdown this is back in line with the growth rate seen since June. November's orders are expected to ease again slightly but still remain above the long-term average.

In wholesaling, after two months of unexpectedly strong growth, 28% saw a drop in sales on a year ago against 40% who reported an increase (a lower than expected balance of +12%). Boosted by the strength of sales in August and September, the three month average was the highest seen since March 1998 (both with a balance of +43%).

Wholesalers of industrial materials cited the strongest year-on-year sales growth, with the balance of +62 being the best since March 2006 (+66%).
Motor traders had an unexpectedly good month. The +33% balance reporting growth is the highest since May 2004 (+34%), driven by sales of vehicles rather than parts and accessories. However, sales were considered average for the time of year, the strong balance being a reflection of last October's very weak reading.

John Longworth, chairman of the CBI's distributive trades panel and executive director at Asda said: "The high street has seen another month of slower growth in retail sales, and although some retailers are doing better than others, it is clear that the buoyant trading period enjoyed earlier this year has tailed off.

"Although slightly better sales are expected in November, retailers' hopes have been disappointed for the past few months, and they anticipate only subdued growth in the important run-up to Christmas. As consumers begin to feel the pinch, they will look to retailers who offer them value for their money."

CBI chief economic adviser Ian McCafferty, said: "The pace of growth in sales has consistently slowed since the summer, showing that the five interest rate rises are having an increasing effect on momentum as shoppers tighten their belts.

"With added uncertainty about the economy because of the credit crunch, we can expect this slower pace to continue next year."

< back to news headlines